Ragu alla Bolognese – Authentic recipe

Bologna crestIn truth there probably isn’t one authentic recipe for Ragu alla Bolognese, but this one is close enough. There are however countless inauthentic ones. It bears little or no resemblance to the dish known as Bolognese or Bolognaise found outside of Italy. It is also never served with Spaghetti!

On October 17, 1982, the Bolognese chapter of the Accademia Italiana della Cucina, “after having carried out long and laborious investigations and conducted studies and research”, announced the following recipe to be the official one. I’m sure that every family in Emilia Romagna has their own version though. Serves 4.

  • 400 grams fresh tagliatelle or fettucine
  • 300 grams minced beef – The recommended cut is thin flank aka skirt (finta cartella in Italian) but any good quality mince will do.
  • 150 grams unsmoked pancetta — minced very finely
  • 50 grams carrot — finely chopped or minced
  • 50 grams celery — finely chopped or minced
  • 50 grams onion — finely chopped or minced
  • 30 grams triple concentrated tomato purée(if using double concentrated, increase the quantity by about a third,  purée is known as “tomato paste” in the US)
  • 1/2 glass red or white wine
  • 180 ml fresh milk
  • olive oil
  • salt and pepper
  1. Fry the pancetta gently in a little olive oil until it starts to release its fat. Be careful not to burn.
  2. Add the vegetables and fry until the onions are transparent, stirring from time to time.
  3. Add the beef and cook until it is lightly browned. When it starts to make popping noises, it’s done.
  4. Add the tomato puree and the wine and mix well.
  5. Add the milk, little by little until it is completely absorbed.
  6. Season with salt and pepper, cover and cook very slowly for 3 to 4 hours.
  7. Stir occasionally and if it looks like drying out, add a little more milk.
  8. Serve with Fettuccine or Tagliatelle (NOT Spaghetti!)
  9. Serve with Parmesan cheese on the side. Alternatively toss the pasta first in a little butter and then in Parmesan before adding the meat sauce.
  • Variation: The Academy allows the addition of Porcini mushrooms.
Bolognese finished dish

Bolognese finished dish

This is a more detailed explanation of the dish from Bologna Cooking School

A ragu Bolognese style is a meat sauce that is slow simmered for at least an hour to develop a complex flavor and proper thickness. Cooking the ragu in a heavy-duty enamel or similar pot will hold the heat steady and help to give a velvety texture to the ragu. Bolognese ragu is a classic sauce for lasagne and tagliatelle. The sauce also freezes beautifully.

Bolognese sauce (ragù alla bolognese in Italian) is a meat- and tomato-based pasta sauce originating in Bologna, Italy. It is typically made by simmering ground meat in tomato sauce, white wine, and stock for a long time (often upward of four hours), so that the meat softens and begins to break down into the liquid medium. The original sauce is not done with minced meat; instead, whole meat, usually beef or veal, is chopped with a knife.
Spaghetti alla Bolognese, or spaghetti bolognese which is sometimes further shortened to spag bol, is a dish invented outside of Italy consisting of spaghetti with a meat sauce. In Italy, this sauce is generally not served with spaghetti because it tends to fall off the pasta and stay on the plate. Instead, the people of Bologna traditionally serve their famous meat sauce with tagliatelle (‘tagliatelle alla bolognese). Outside the traditional use, this sauce can be served with tubular pasta or represent the stuffing for lasagna or cannelloni.

While “Bolognese” is undoubtedly the most popular ragù in this country, it is also the most misunderstood.
The ragù you get by that name is usually a characterless tomato sauce with pea-like bits of ground beef floating in it, bearing little resemblance to anything you’d find in Bologna.
And not, in any sense, a ragù.
True ragù alla Bolognese contains no tomato sauce — just enough fresh or canned tomato to add a hint of sweetness and another layer of flavor to a subtle, complex mix. Like all ragùs, Bolognese is characterized by its long, slow cooking, which in this case starts with simmering the meat in milk (to mellow the acidity of the raw tomatoes added later) and wine (some use white, others red), after which the tomatoes are added. The whole lot is cooked together for about two hours

About these ads

151 thoughts on “Ragu alla Bolognese – Authentic recipe

  1. Hello Chris,
    I hope you are well.
    I was looking for inspiration and found it with this recipe. It sounds super and I’ll try it when Dietlinde returns from the Spa and post another comment then.
    Unexpectedly I also found the link to my web page. Many thanks for that.
    Best wishes
    John

  2. Hi John

    I can’t claim credit for adding the link to your site, the system does it automatically. I will however post a link on the main page (next to Michael’s :-) )

    I hope you both enjoy the recipe, I did :-)

    Chris

  3. I set out to make this, with a promise that I would stick to the recipe, even though I wasn’t sure where the flavour would come from. In the end, I couldn’t do it. With just 30 gms of the tomato puree and so much milk (about 3/4 of a cup?) my sauce came out an orange-tinged grey tone. This can’t be right. It looked very unappetizing and had no tomato flavour. I ended up adding a big can of drained/pureed/strained plum tomatoes and a full can of tomato paste. Then it looked more like your photo and tasted more like the RB we enjoyed so much on the Ligurian coast last summer. I thought I would let you know so you can double check the quantities you listed. 30 grams of concentrated tomato puree proved to be a bit less than 4 Tbsp by my scale.

  4. Hi oottagerswife

    Thanks for taking the time to comment, it’s nice to receive such detailed feedback.

    I wasn’t sure where the flavour would come from

    The flavour comes primarily from the meat. There are many version of Ragu in Italy. This recipe is specifically for the version commonly served in Bologna and deposited in the archive of Accademia Italiana della Cucina.

    and had no tomato flavour

    The Bolognese version of ragu shouldn’t have a strong tomato taste. The tomatoes should just add an extra ‘note’. As I mentioned in the article, this recipe is not very similar to the ‘spag bog’ we are used to in the UK or to the ‘red sauce’ they are used to in the USA.

    One thing I forgot to mention, however, is the quantities of tomato puree are for triple concentrated. If you use double concentrated you can increase the quantity. I’ve amended the recipe to make that clear.

    sauce came out an orange-tinged grey tone

    As you can see from the photo, mine came out a quite dark, rich colour. I’m not sure what went wrong with yours. How long did you cook it for?

    Anyway, thanks again for the feedback and I’m sorry the recipe didn’t turn out as you expected.

  5. Hi Ella

    You must be my most loyal visitor :-) It really is a great recipe. I look forward to hearing how you got on.

    Chris

  6. I am still waiting for my loyalty card;)

    I thought this recipe was very very good! Nothing like the bolognaise I usually make. The flavour definately came from the meat and the flavour was much more intense than I had expected.

    I hang my head in shame though ……….. it didn’t seem right serving it with tagliatelle!!!!!

    Yours, a still surprised and now ashamed as well,
    Ella

  7. I hang my head in shame though ……….. it didn’t seem right serving it with tagliatelle!!!!!

    LOL I’ll let you off this time :-)

    Glad you enjoyed it.

  8. Good evening Chris.

    First the confession.

    I was unable to obtain pancetta – Interspar said they used to stock it- and I had to substitute Speckwürfel from Austria. I imagine Interspar don’t stock pancetta as there is a ‘similar’ product produced in Austria.

    That said I followed the remainder of the recipe and we were pleased with the outcome. It tasted very well and looked much like your illustration.

    I must find a source for pancetta and try it again.

    My best wishes

    John

  9. Hi John

    I’m sure Speckwürfel is a very acceptable substitution. Am I right in thinking that the rough English translation is ‘bacon bits’ ? You could even used minced belly pork if that’s easier to find.

    All the best

    C

  10. I’ll eat it with spaghetti if I want to. This nonsensical fetish about “authenticity” helps no one. If it tastes good, eat it. It’s food. Celebrate.

    • It’s not to do with authenticity actually. It is all to do with what tastes best. Spaghetti is so thin and round that it does not allow the meat and sauce to grip to it. If it tasted better with Spaghetti then that is what they would probably eat it with, but it doesn’t so they don’t.

  11. Hi. My name is George and i am from Bulgaria. I love the Italian food but here in bulgaria all i have ate is just shit. We have only one italian restaurant and it is very good but it is in one town on the seacoast but i live in the capital city Sofia which is maybe 500km away from it…sooo i decided to make today Ragu alla Bolognese but i had few problems with the ingredients…i don’t even know(even after i searched in the net) what is this Pancetta but i think the closest to it what can i find in the supermarket is beacon…i hope my attempt to do this ragu will be successful and i’ll write you after the dinner :)
    P.S.
    I don’t have any idea how i’m gonna do it with tomatoes, not tomato sauce :X

  12. Hi Georgi, nice to hear from you.

    Pancetta is a type of italian dry cured bacon. If you can’t find it then you can use bacon (preferably unsmoked) or minced pork (belly or something similar). I look forward to hearing how you get on.

    Cheers :-)

  13. I can say only one thing…Mamma mia! :) Everything was great. But i cooked it for about 2 hours not as it’s written – 3-4 hours, cause i haven’t got much time. BUT it was great. It was so delicious. But i had one little problem as “cottagerswife”…my sauce was also a little bit like orange or maybe red but it wasn’t so dark like the one from the photo…i don’t know why this happened…but i think it’s because most of the ingredients i put were not the same like the ones from the recipe. Instead of minced beef i put the closest thing i found in the supermarket in my building which was mixture of minced beef and pork(60:40). Instead of 150 grams unsmoked pancetta i put 150gr beacon(i don’t know if it was unsmoked,smoked,coked,choked,soaked or anything else). I put tomato puree which i don’t even know what type was BUT IT WAS ITALIAN and for that reason it costed me maybe 5 times the price of the regular puree but i wanted everything to be perfectly Italian or as close as possible. And maybe my biggest mistake was that i cooked it for a short period of time, because i was in a hurry, cause my guests started to come…guests…who am i kidding…they were 2 people…and one of them didn’t like the sauce…now he sleeps in a coffin…forever… :) soooo that’s all from me and my italian adventure in the kitchen :) i’ll search here for another interesting recipes and i’ll discuss the result with you :)
    P.S. I’m 18 years old and these are my first steps into cooking so don’t expect big things(you’ll see me posting comments only in the recipes for very easy-to-make dishes) haha :D
    Best wishes from Bulgaria :)

    • I was surprised that you said the Italian food in Bulgaria is not too good. Since it is somewhat close geographically. But sure, the two cultures are very different and use different types of foods and ingredients.

      I’m Italian American and I guess I could say the same type thing- There are some very good Italian restaurants in the USA and also a ton of bad ones. Only the absolute best of the best, maybe only 1% or 2% of them, recreate real Italian cuisine as you would find in Italy. Anyway, glad it worked out for you! maybe you partner with an Italian and you will start a good Italian restaurant there? ;-)

  14. Pingback: Link dump: A bunch of recipes I want to try « Nikki’s Link Blog

  15. Tremendous websit – thrilled to have found it. Currently do the Ragu. Already a couple key errors in the measurements with a result of too much indulgance in white wine and bad math skills. basically 30% too much of the carrot/onion/celery. I had 500gms of mince beef to which I combined 450gms of Pork loin (beaten with a tenderiser and cubed) and 100gms of bacon. I would have prefferred neck of pork- under slow simmered it would be delightful. I prepared half of the pork cubed and half slice in the chinese style to see which breaks down better. the recipe is not far from Hester Bleumanthuels (did I spell his name right?) recipe of the same. will report back on the outcome but suspect the overdose of veg will make for a more intense flavour than required.
    cheers

  16. I have been on mission to make many ragus – afterI included a ragu story/tale/heated argument in my youth play CIAO CINDERELLA. This looks delicious and will try it. Last night made a ragu with sweet Italian sausage (from TASTES OF ITALIA) and it was a winner. I do agree that the slow simmering really melds the flavors into somethingwonderfull complex – and attractive. Glad to have found this blog!

  17. Hi Are you using tomato puree or tomato paste(usually double or triple concentrated from a tube).I am not familiar with triple concentrated puree and have a really good knowledge of food products.In any event I am still on a quest for the perfect bolognese.I have seen this recipe before but have not tried it because of the puree and milk additive versus paste and cream.Do you possibly have the non metric conversion for the recipe as I’m math challenged.Whats your thoughts about the classic cream addition versus cooking it lowly and slowly with milk which does make sense.Chuck

    • Hi Chuck

      I’m sorry you find the recipe confusing. Here’s a link with some pictures which may help you Tomato Products

      For the non metric version, Google has a rather nice conversion feature. Just type in, for example, 75g in oz and it”ll give you the result. AS a rough guide 25g=1oz

      HTH

  18. Pingback: The Edible Festival » Blog Archive » The Slow Food Guide to Dating - Dinner and a Movie in Bologna, Italy

  19. Im at it again. Not drinking too much wine this time! Have now done probably a 17 variations of the Ragu/ bolongaise theme, borrowing from various recipes to come up with my own final all time best formula. Some disasters (not too bad), one incredible outcome – and I have had ragu from all corners of this globe including some of the ‘best’ from Italy. The only problem is that Im still trying to unravel what I did – I will say what I did was so outlandish im embarressed to put it in print until re-tested.

    Non the less some tips for the punters. Use a dry white (Savingon Blanc or chenin blanc). Nothing else cuts it. A bay leaf helps a bit if you are into it. For the Gourmond – finely chop a fresh chicken liver (or two!) and add (raw) the simmering ragu. My wife would have gagged if she knew what I did – instead only great compliments and no mention of chicken liver ‘taste’. In short it gives an after ‘note’ and certain depth of flavour i have never achieved before. If you reheat the next day – incredibly more milk and grated carrot (not pan fried – just straight in) revs it up (the liver version that is !)

    Good luck.

  20. HI: I followed the recipie as closely as possible converting the metric portions to US weights & measures. I cooked the ragu for the required four hours adding a tablespoon of sugar at hour three. I used ground beef and white wine ( a riesling from the bottom shelf of our local supermarket, I do not know wines!) The color was perfect, and the taste, wonderful. I served it with fresh fetticucine and grated parmigino regiano (sp?). Had the same dish in Rome last week and this was equally as good!!

    PJ Mesa

  21. Hi Chris,

    Great site BTW !! Have tried this great recept a few times now. Bacon is a good subsitute but i found that dried raw ham (any variaty just as long as it’s not smoked) gives a very nice result.Also (probably a cardinal sin but still….) I added about 100ml of beef fond (fond! NOT bouillon )it was absolutly increadable, an enormous taste explosion!! :-)Same idea i suppose as fatdogs chicken liver …it really brings out the meatyness!

    Anyway great job and keep em coming!!!

    • Hi Patrick. Thanks for the feedback.

      The raw ham option sound like a good idea if you can afford it. I’m ashamed to admit that I’ve no idea what fond is though. Is it a kind of stock concentrate?

      Cheers

  22. Fond is indeed a sort of stock but its made from the scrapings at the bottom of the pan.So it’s very concentrated. A sort of gravy base I suppose. Here in europe you can buy it as a liquid in pots in any good supermarket.

  23. Pingback: pasta puttanesca - Page 2 - ChefTalk Cooking Forums

    • Yes that is correct, no garlic.

      Genuine Italian food generally contains much less garlic than people imagine. I think its garlicky reputation probably comes from Italian-American recipes rather than from native Italian ones.

      That said, if you like garlic, put some in :-)

  24. Hi there,
    Ivan’s here, Italian who lives in Fiji since too many year now.
    I’ve just posted my very own recipe of the ragu’ alla bolognese. My recipe comes from years looking at my mum and grand ma and it is not too distant from yours. Just a question.. why not spaghetti?
    all the best and keep cooking good food!

    • Thanks Ivan :-)

      I think the argument against spaghetti is that it doesn’t hold the sauce very well. The ragu tends to be left behind on the plate after you’ve eaten all the pasta. That’s the theory anyway. The real reason is probably “that’s the way my mama did it” :-)

      • Hi again,
        in deed you are right, I myself am not a spaghetti lover that much but my wife, well that is a different story. In the end, as you say, we are the cook we grew to be.
        great blog anyway, i’ll talk to you at our next recipe.
        Have a great weekend

    • Hi Ivan I’m looking for the perfect bolognese recipe and your one sounded good since it was from your grandmother! Could you please write up the website for me. Many thanks Pamela from Australia

  25. Hi!

    I cooked your recipe exactly as described and fell in love with it. Its so much better than the sugar laden jarred stuff we buy here in Australia. Now that im off interstate for a few days im cooking a bumper batch to see my wife and baby girl through. Great work with the site, when will we see some new recipes? :p Cheers.

  26. I just got back from a one month stay in Bologna. Here is my report on how they serve it there. In case you want to make it similar to how they do there. First of all the color of the ragu was always orange. I never had a dark red one like that picture. I had the ragu at all the places famous for Bolognese cuisine like Diana’s, and Melloncello, and the Ragu was always orange in color. There was little to no tomato flavor at all. One thing I also noticed that was different from the picture is that the meat wasn’t finely ground in Bologna, there was always little chunks of ground meat as well. It is mostly a beefy flavor and the noodles would turn orange when mixed with the meat sauce. It was always served with either tagliatelle or lasgna verde. just a dollop in the middle.

    Oh and the pasta there is just so much better there. The fresh pasta is always a golden yellow. This comes from the fact that the eggs there have a dark orange color yolk, Also they add a lot of eggs to the pasta. The best pasta I had was at a place called Drogheria del Rossa, and the owner said he used 10 eggs per 1 kilo of flour. The texture was amazing. I never realized how could pasta could be, and it’s probably a reason why the sauces on pasta there just barely cover it, because they don’t like overwhelming the the pasta. They do serve the sauce just like you show in the picture though.
    Also I would assume if they were to use a red wine, it would be Sangiovese, its the local speciality along with Lambrusco.

    This is definately tasted authentic. I used flank steak instead, and used 3 tablespoons of double concentrate mixed with 3 tablespoons of water. Also I used 10 ounces of milk. I don’t know any cows so couldn’t get any fresh milk. I’m not sure how your’s turned out so red, mine wasn’t even close. It was more the color of the beef with a slighty orangish tone.

    One more tip, i think they chop the vegetables and panchetta so fine that they eventually melt, probably using a fine cheese grater or food processor, because I never saw bits of them in any of the ragu’s I had there.

    • Hi Jamie

      Thanks very much for the info. First a confession. The photo above is a little deceptive and is far more orange than it appears. I didn’t want to admit it earlier to cottagerswife because I had been put on the defensive by the tone of her comment. Oh vanity ;-) You’re always caught out in the end :-)

      It sounds like you went to one of the few restaurants that still chops the meat by hand rather than use a mincer. This used to be the traditional way, but it’s becoming rarer nowadays.

      Totally agree about homemade pasta. It is so much better than even shop bought so-called “fresh” pasta. Why not have a go making it yourself. It’s not as difficult as most people think. Here’s a link to the method. http://culinariaitalia.wordpress.com/2007/12/28/fresh-pasta/

      Totally agree about chopping the veg and pancetta finely. I can never be bothered to do it by hand.

      Finally – fresh milk lol. When I said fresh milk, I didn’t mean freshly squirted out of a cow :-) I mean not UHT or homogenised or other such abomination.

      Anyway, thanks for your comments. It sounds like you had a great time.

      • hey dj,

        thanks for the link on how to make pasta. I’m planning on trying to make some soon for a lasagna verde using the ragu. The lasagna is the best in Bologna. I love the fact that they don’t use ricotta or tomato sauce in it over there.

        I’m not sure if they mince the meat or just don’t break up the ground meat as much but here are two pictures of different ragu’s I took while there. I would be curious to know because it seems like you loose a ton of the fat from the meat in the grinding process.

        The first picture is from Melloncello, the second is the Lasagna Verde from Diana’s.

        One thing I noticed about the pasta there was that there was always little bumps or bubbles on the pasta which you can see in the picture.

        ha i know, I was joking about the milk.

    • Bingo- excellente…..lol I am Italian American live in suberbs outdside of Philadelphia- my bolognese and my gravy (sauce to most others) is orange in color and most italians i know that are actually from Italy theirs is orange as well- it does depend on the tomato product you use and it also depends on the oil or oil based product (from the meat, etc) because that tends to oil it up and lessen the redness- the deeper color can sometimes come from meat or maybe even overcooking actually at too high a flame- i am not suggesting lesson the time at all for goodness sake….lol it should cook for at least 4 hours i know there are ways to shorten and thats fine when you are in a pinch but if you want to feel like you are in italy with a nice glass of wine and beautiful music by all means let it simmer all day- bacon is fine or any similar thick fatty ham type product but nothing like maple smoked or anything that would throw the flavor off or offer any sweetness – despite what people have been led to believe a ragu, marinara, gravy whatever you want to call it should never never never never be sweet if it is then save yourself time and open a jar which i could never bring myself to do it is not the same- as an italian you can make a quick marinara version in less than a half hour and it taste so much better- for my meat I use pancetta or in a pinch a bacon type product- veal or pork and beef- as far as the pasta it should be something that the sauce will stick to- another trick is dont rinse your pasta so the starchs will help the sauce stick and if you are making just enough for dinner you should actually add the pasta right into the pot with the bolognese and it will all stick together- i make huge batches because my daughter and husband will actually just put it in a bowl and eat it without the pasta before and after dinner- crazy……. i would not be able to write own the recipe i just measure as i go- the color also depends on the wine you use- surprisingly some italians use red wine but that will deepen the color as well i use dry white hence allowing the color to stay more orange in color……. i think the original recipe seems fine sorry i didnt try it i just make my own but your ingredients in nature seem fine- the picture does look dark but that could be many reasons. Unfortunately some people will love it and some wont its what happens when you put yourself out there in the public but shrug it off and keep doing what you do- its awesome!

      • :-) Thanks for the comments. The picture makes the ragù look much darker than it actually is. As I said, I didn’t want to admit this to cottagerswife.

  27. Pingback: Recipe: Ragu alla Bolognese « MelDabbles

  28. Pingback: My bolognese style sauce - ChefTalk Cooking Forums

  29. I made this today with a few variations. I had no celery so I added a bit of celery seed. I also used more tomato and subbed beer for the wine as I had no wine and am snowed in. The pancetta was pre-minced, and I hand minced the beef. Next time I’ll try making homemade pasta. This is an excellent recipe you’ve posted!

    Andrea from Kentucky

  30. Dear Chris-

    I am so delighted to have found the “authentic” recipe for bolognese sauce. (I plan to make it for a friend whom I haven’t seen for 20 years, but who made me one of my most memorable meals.)

    Would you recommend buying flank steak and “mincing” it in the food processor, as opposed to buying ground beef?

    Thanks, Ellen

    p.s. I understand from another blog that the Bolognese Chamber of Commerce has copyrighted a recipe nearly identical to this one. Thanks again.

    • Hi Ellen

      Thanks for dropping in. The really authentic way is to chop the meat by hand with a knife. That said, I’ve never met anyone here who still does it that way. I use the best quality minced/ground beef I can find. Probably the best way would be to use an old fashioned handcranked mincer, if you can find one and mince your own. I’d be very wary of using a food processor as it would be very easy to get the texture wrong and end up with paste.

      Yes, you’re right. This is the Chamber of commerce recipe. It’s wasn’t actually copyrighted, but declared to be the one official recipe (and probably nearly caused a civil war in the process ;-) ) See the first paragraph of the text.

      Cheers

      Chris

  31. Chris-

    Thank you for your feedback. I do have a grinder, and if I have time, I will grind the meat myself. If I don’t have time, if you use the best quality ground beef, that’s good enough for me! :)

    I laughed at your comment regarding the near civil war. I am just glad you provided the “official” authentic (I know it’s redundant) recipe.

    Thanks, and have a great day!
    Ellen
    San Diego, CA

  32. Dear Chris,

    This recipe was an eye opener for me. I was unsure and checked with my Italian relative first, she consulted her cookbooks and then I went ahead, unsure of outcome. I didn’t want to waste all my expensive pancetta. I followed your recipe almost exactly, finely chopping everything with a super sharp knife..but added half quantity of milk supplemented with stock (sorry, wasn’t daring enough to add all)..and also added a little extra tomato puree on top of the triple concentrate. I did a triple batch – so I added 300gm tomato puree for 900gm mince. Well I have to say the recipe is exquisite. It was a completely different coking experience and a revelationb to me about the meat absorbing the wine and milk. I will never go back to the old, but I’m afraid now of being a snob. I make in triple batches and portion out serves for freezer, making a beautiful quick, mid week meal after work.

  33. Hi,
    Thanks for this amazing recipe. I had never had this until a friend whipped some up for the children’s dinner and all the adults were jealous!!
    I have one question. What is triple concentrated puree and is it available in the US? I went to the market with your list above and the italian aisle had no such thing. We have a choice of either puree or paste, nothing says concentrated. In fact, some of the cans of puree say they contain concentrate and water, and some of the cans say not from concentrate. The paste just says tomatoes for the ingredients.
    My friend had used tomato paste in his recipe but like I said, it was whipped up using mostly leftovers for the children and I didn’t think to ask him if that was the “correct” ingredient.
    Thanks for clearing this up.
    Wendy

  34. Tried this recipe at the weekend and it turned out fantastic! I had it with Conchiglie and it was delicious… Not sure if it is allowed to with this type of pasta but it holds the ragu very well.

  35. Pingback: TDH-pastaa | -mip-

  36. Pingback: Quick Meals from Slow Food « FUSSYlittleBLOG

  37. Hi there. I just tried your ragu and it was great i lived in Italy as a child and had family in bologna. Your recipe was just as good if not better. i’m very impressed, havent used so much milk in my ragu before :)

    • Thanks a lot for your very flattering comment Rikki :-) I’m afraid I can’t claim credit for the recipe though, only the translation.

  38. No doubt this recipe is very authentic and I make mine fairly similar- this year I will be doing it with the flank steak and pancetta – in the past I have sub’d in chunks of Prosciutto or Guanciale for pancetta depending on what was on hand- I agree Spaghetti just can not hold the sauce-

    For Thanksgiving I plan on making a 10-15 layer lasagnia with homemade noodle and bolognese sauce layered between each layer of pasta as our pasta dish before the Turkey- I always use dry white wine in mine and agree with what others have stated it is what we call Tomato Paste here in the states- I like to do the vegetables in the food processor which help them melt and I grind my meats- in the past I have included short rib and prime sirloin into my meat mixture just vor taste variation-

    I will spend some time going through the rest of your site tonight-

  39. The milk must be integrated into meat before adding the tomatoes and after the white/red wine.

    Also important is to add salt just when adding the meat. This contributes a lot, as the salt releases the juices from the meat, adding value the the finished product.

  40. I made this last night and it was very good. I searched for a recipe because I had all of the ingredients in the fridge and they needed to be used up. I had a thin cut sirloin steak, hot Italian sausage, prosciutto, some half & half, sauvignon blanc, a very ripe tomato, tomato paste, and homemade beef stock. I hand chopped the steak into about a half inch dice and seasoned it with garlic & onion powders, salt, pepper. I removed the sausage from its casing and sauteed it after the prosciutto had crisped. I pretty much followed the recipe, but I did add some minced garlic, parsley and oregano. Gotta have it. Make sure you get a good caramelization on the mirepoix. This was really delicious and tasted even better the next day. What people have to understand is that Bolognese is a MEAT sauce, not a tomato sauce. The flavor of the meat is front and center, not tomatoes. Thanks for the excellent recipe. It is very authentic.

  41. Chris. Substituted the tomato paste for ketchup and used Don Pedro wine from a carton and it worked a treat. How you getting on, by the way, after your wee spell in hospital? Stevie, Liberec

    • Sounds good! (shudder…) :-)

      Hi Stevie!

      I’m fine. Just about back to normal. A little slower now though.

      I believe that congrats are in order for the second baby. I’ll get all the news from H who is arriving in a couple of weeks.

      Cheers

      Chris

      • OMG I think I shuddered with you i am so sorry I dont want to be mean but ketchup no no no no please……

        • Lol. I know Stevie very well and he’s joking. The amount of quite nasty abuse I’ve blocked for this post (not yours I hasten to add) I thought I’d better comment. HE IS JOKING :-)

  42. Pingback: Is Real Bolognese Sauce Made With Cream or Milk? - brightonyourhealth | brightonyourhealth

  43. Pingback: Spaghetti alla Bolognese : Personal Blog or The Numbness Continues

  44. Pingback: Recipe–Cooking for the Year–Day 2 = Beef | My Whit's End

  45. I think the point of this sauce is to use good meat. This not your usual spag bol sauce where you throw in any old thing from the herb cupboard. I followed the recipe to the T. I used minced Veal (from Waitrose), Cirico Double Concentrated puree (I added an extra 10g as recipe suggest if you dont have treble concentrate), glass of White wine (Italian of course). I minced the pancetta in the food processor and diced the veg very finely. Cooked for 3.5 hours, served with Tagliatelli. It was superb….absolutely fantastic. Italain food is about simplicity and all these basic ingredients enhanced the meat perfectly. I was sceptical at first..no garlic, no herbs….but follow the recipie, get the best ingridients you can afford and it will be beautiful.

  46. I had to endure 3 of silly Delia Smith’s pages, then about another 4 before I landed on here. I still wouldn’t use milk in any meat recipe though, but then, cooking is all about one’s own tastes, not someone elses’. I always use garlic, but other than that, this is more or less the recipe I’ve been using for decades. I’ve read dozens and dozens of “authentic Italian ragu/bolognese recipes” over the years and I have yet to find 2 that are identical. As I said, it’s all a matter of taste.
    Same with “authentic” chilli recipes…but that’s another country altogether!

    • Hi Sandra. You are quite right, cooking is all about one’s own tastes. This recipe is marked as authentic because it is the one registered at Accademia Italiana della Cucina. I am sure every family has its own though.

    • I kind of have the same feeling regarding milk and meat. Making a ragu like this I will use dry white wine and maybe even mix in a little veal stock throughout the cooking, as well as using finely chopped veal for about a third part of the total meat content. I would also recommend to make this with moose meat, it probably wouldn’t pass the authenticity test though. :-)

  47. I’m making this ragu with lasagna for a dinner party tonight. It appears spot on ingredients and technique wise, I’ll let you know how it turns out!
    Thanks for the authentic recipe.

  48. First i would like to say thank you for a brilliant recipe and second could you please put up a recipe for naples ragu as i am sick of the terrible food served under pretense in the uk.

    Thanks again
    S

  49. Made this recently while introducing my girlfriend to proper Italian food, as opposed to the sad travesties served in most Japanese Italian restaurants. Absolutely phenomenal. Thanks for a great recipe!

  50. I can taste the recipe as it is being read. Thank you! Also, I encourage all chefs to cook boldly and to inadvertently make mistakes as nothing can educate you more quickly. My poor wife has been over peppered by my heavy hand and also the lucky recipient of of heaven on a plate. My approach is to just dice away, some proportional quantity (as opposed to measuring) and place it in there, allow your sight and your olfactory senses to guide you. Many times I add a little more of something as I watch the ingredients coming together. You will be richly rewarded.

  51. I live in India where some of the ingredients for Italian cooking are not readily available. My ragu so far has required me to cheat and add a couple of spoons of ready-made sauce from a jar. Now for the first time I feel encouraged to try this recipe.
    However can I use penne or fusili instead of tagliatele, as the latter is difficult to source. Also instead of pancetta, I plan to use local bacon minced fine.

    • Penne (rigate) or fusilli would probably hold the sauce quite well. Also if the bacon is good quality it should be fine. Good luck.

  52. Pingback: Eating All'aperto in Fresh Air Italy: 5 Days and 5 Primi Piatti | BrightonYourHealth

  53. Hi all, i’ve found this forum cause i was looking for recipes already translated in english for an US friend :-)

    I happen to be from Bologna, and while the image looks ok, i’ve never heard we use pancetta (even less bacon) for our typical ragu. We instead use sausage (i dont know if what we call sausage can be found outside Italy though) and its a of course a sausage but made of fresh pork meat minced with pepper, enveloped in the intestines of the pork. We usually dont use concentrated tomato but those convenient bottled ones you can find anywhere here :-)

    Ideally the best pasta for ragu is tagliatelle hands down, then you can use others, but for tradition its tagliatelle :-)

  54. This recipe is really an eye opener for me. But where I come from, pancetta isn’t readily available. Can I use bacon as a substitute?

  55. In Italy they never put the ragu or sauce on top of the pasta! they always mix it and usually put back on fire for one more minute, so the flavours mix together even better. ( I was living in Italy for 2 years and I ate every single day at least once pasta:))
    The recepee is excellent, though:)

  56. This recipe is excellent for its simplicity. In the end, isn’t the point of a dish like this supposed to be about using what’s on hand? I think it is.

    If you want to use bacon I say do it. If you want to swap in US style tomato paste for the puree, go to town!. Change the proportion of carrots to celery, or vice versa? You have my blessing (which is worth exactly what you paid for it).

    Recipes are guidelines, not gospel (unless you are baking. Baking is science–cooking is art). If you’ve prepared a dish more than twice and haven’t varied something you aren’t cooking. You’d save time by buying boxed dinners and following the directions exactly.

    This isn’t to discourage those posters above who have obsessed somewhat about ingredients. It’s to encourage them to stop it, and give stuff a try.

    Bon appetit.

    • Of course Lawnboy you are correct, if you want to have a wonderful tagliatelle all’united states, but if you want to try to eat the real thing, sadly you have to comply to a true recipe, which is gospel if you will. Else i could tell you please enjoy my texas hamburger made with tofu between 2 slices of rice bread :-)

      • i understand the concept of a certified authentic recipe. I don’t think any less of anyone who follows this one to the letter.

        But when I started chopping vegetables today in order to make this dish for the zillionth time since I discovered it here I didn’t realize I had no olive oil (I used butter to saute the veg instead). I knew already that I had no pancetta and although I could easily get it at any large Supermarket here on the west coast of the US I find that regular supermarket bacon or a combo of bacon and supermarket ham works ok. I honestly don’t think I could tell the difference in a blind taste test.

        The first time I made ragu alla bolognese I used this recipe exactly as written, right down to the tagiatelle. I’ve never done that since, and I probably never will. Tonights offering will have the substitutions listed above and it will be served with penne rigate because fresh tagliatelle is a pain.

        I’m an equal opportunity adulterator. My cornish pasties use butter instead of lard, my red beans and rice will often use something other than andouille and sometimes will substitute green chilies for some of the green peppers. I make reno red chili with a spoonful of cocoa powder added in the last 10 min of simmering just to give it a undefinable layer of underneath flavor. You do not want to know what I do with my coq au vin. But damn it tastes good.

        The common thread is that all these dishes are everyday food. Peasant food if you like. They evolved from cooks using what was on hand. There is nothing wrong with Italian culinary authorities certifying that this recipe is THE one for this dish. There is something wrong with not cooking it because you’re short an ingredient. It’ll still be great!

        • “You do not want to know what I do with my coq au vin. But damn it tastes good. ”
          Nothing sexual I hope. You make a good point though. I put a very small bit of garlic in my alfredo sauce and also a very small bit of cream. Traditionally it is an all butter sauce with no garlic, but I just prefer it the way I make it. So shoot me.

  57. Pingback: Bolognese « Running Slimmer

      • Thank you again for standing up to my American compatriots who want to leap to conclusions without getting the point of sophisticated TRADITIONAL Italian cuisine.

        Just try this recipe faithfully, reserve judgment and you may experience a major culinary epiphany!!! And go ahead, if it’s your desire, smoke a cigarette after.

    • What makes Italian food so elegant, is the simplicity and interaction of it’s ingredients. Too many ingredients complicate the delicate balance.

    • I lived in Bologna for a year and ate tagliatelli a ragu at least once a week. They don’t add any spices or garlic to the ragu, but the depth of flavor the ingredients take on after two hours of cooking is indescribably amazing. In fact, when asking a bolognese native whether they added garlic to the sauce, because it’s so flavorful, he almost had a heart attack. I also watch out for the amount of salt I use in the beginning, especially with the pancetta or proscuitto because of how concentrated the sauce gets.

      • Ha ha. I think that is a safe assumption. I think some people miss the point of this sauce, it is somewhat unique for Italian sauces, and that is part of what makes it so special. Adding garlic or herbs would be heresy. Actually, true Alfredo sauce has no garlic either, just butter and Parmesan. And yes, carbonara sauce should not contain garlic or herbs either. Although being from a Southern Italian family(Napoli), I put just a very small bit of garlic in my Alfredo, about half of a small clove or one tiny clove, and of course, *freshly* minced parsley on top.

  58. Pingback: Spaghetti Bolognese « Spaghetti Bolognese

  59. Pingback: Semi-Authentic Bolognese Ragu | eat. drink. cook. travel.

  60. I just wanted to mention to the article’s author, that flank and skirt steaks are two different cuts of meat. I first used the flank steak as suggested. This is a real wonderful recipe I would recommend to anyone who is interested in understanding the basics of northern Italian cuisine. Thanks for sharing it.

  61. I finally got around to updating the picture of the finished dish. I was very English in the way I served it. This pic is much more representative of how it should be served.

    DJ

  62. What an amazing site! I made this ragu last night and received nothing but praise. As a lover of Italian food I often am frustrated by the substandard recipes online. This blog has given me plenty of inspiration and I will continue to try other recipes posted here! Thankyou for this.

  63. Hi Chris- we all went to Italy separately this year and my family has taken this recipe on with gusto! Its absolutely delicious and we’re even featuring it on our Christmas Even Menu.

    Thank you much

  64. Hi Chris

    I’ve made this recipe five or six times over the past year. It has come out really well every time. It’s a true classic and the family love it, including my 18-month old son. I think one key to it is getting the best pasta you can – ideally homemade if you have the time. Pork lardons work well as a substitute if you can’t get decent pancetta.

    Thanks so much posting the recipe.

    Mark (UK)

  65. Love this, so glad I found your site. After traveling to Italy last year, my husband and I are having great fun bringing Italy to our home. Homemade pasta was the BEST skill we brought home. Now we are having a blast with sauces.
    I am struggling with the same issue as several others regarding Tomato puree. I see your link to http://culinariaitalia.wordpress.com/ingredients-explained/tomato-products/ but cannot read the labels. In the my city/country, the “paste” is thick enough to stand up on its own if you were to remove the top, bottom and sides from the can (very thick). “puree” is definitely a liquid consistency, you can pour it. Any comments? PS I settled on paste.

    • I think you are probably right. Here, “puree” means a type heavily concentrated tomato product usually sold in tubes or cans. What you know as “puree” sounds more like pasatta

  66. Pingback: Italy’s National Dish – Ragu alla Bolognese and Pizza | Roasted Montreal

  67. I make my ragu with water instead of milk. I’m very curious to try it your way.. I got my recipe from my Italian teacher, his family is from Bologna.
    Thanks for putting this recipe up, it’s very helpful :)

  68. Excellent find for me. I have been looking for recipes using skirt steak and am getting tired of asian type dishes, but they are a bit fast and furious. This is easy peasy and totally delicious. No work at all, just time. I’ve tried it a few times now and I think the next time I shall have to try making my own fresh pasta. It’s not as if one is ever rushed making this ragu. Skirt steak is the meat for this, it gives the most wonderful flavour.

  69. I made this for an Italian guest. He asked “Can I call you Mama?”
    I think that’s probably the biggest compliment my cooking has ever got!

  70. Pingback: Piccini Chianti Reserva 2009 | Top of the Wine List

  71. I used a stainless steel small saucepan since the enameled pot was occupied by another food. I guess it was a mistake to utilize the said equipment because uneven stirring caused a few scorching burn mark on the bottom of the pan. As the result, I didn’t let it simmer long enough (less than an hour) to develop the flavor. I believe cast iron or non-stick might be more suitable to make this ragu.

    It was also impossible to find pancetta in predominant non-pork-eating population (Indonesia), so I had to use streaky bacon as the substitute.

    Another mistake that I made was the mincing process. I believe that I didn’t mince the vegetables fine enough. Next time, I would employ food processor to do the job. Same problem also happened with the beef & the bacon. It was regretful that the meat department where I bought the meat didn’t posses any grinder, which was ridiculous.

    I’d do better next time. It was so disappointing when the ragu tasted bland; the meat was still stringy & chunky.

  72. My 2nd attempt yielded much better result. I employed a heavy bottom stainless steel skillet this time, and no more scorching occurred on the bottom of the pan. I simmered the ragu for about 3 hours, and the result was fantastic. I will try adding a pinch of nutmeg like Marcela Hazan’s version next time to see if the flavor can be improved further.

  73. A little secret from a good friend from Bologna. Fry a chicken leg in olive oil. Set aside. In the rendered fat, subsitute the pancetta for a high quality and rich salsiccia. Instead of the tomato concentrate, use seeded and purees San Marzano tomatoes. Then carry on with the recipe adding the chicken leg. As the ragu simmers and the chicken leg cooks, fish out the skin and bones from the chicken leg. Use cream instead of milk. Spend more time simmering down the Ragu at low heat with a large dose of patience and you will be rewarded with a Ragu that will impress the purist….

    Ciao Ciao!

    Federico

  74. Pingback: Maten, kärleken och döden Del 2. Det blir lördagsmiddag med Maffian. | Carinas blogg

  75. Hi I think a lot of people missed the point. An authentic ragu Bolognese isn’t about making necessarily the most delicious sauce ever, it is about experiencing what (some of) the people in Bologna know as their own sauce. Don’t get me wrong, this recipe is one of my favourites. But there can be others without milk and with garlic and herbs but they are just not an authentic Bolognese sauce. In the same way a Thai curry and an Indian curry can both be delicious but they are different. I love this sauce and my kids don’t complain so that’s the real bonus!

  76. Pingback: The Cook’s Couch Episode 1: Bolognese and Venture Brothers | The Passion of the Grice

  77. II just joined your interesting “Bog” – tried printing and e-mailing a recipe – the page indicates “loading” but was unsuccessful ?
    Please advise.

  78. Sorry for the typos, but the “reply” box has printing on it and I wasn’t able to see what I was typing. By the way, I was interested in the “autentic” Ragu sauce to compare with mine from a cousin in Italy. Thank you. Diane

  79. Pingback: Off to Bologna to Enjoy Tagliatelle Ragù Bolognese | BrightonYourHealthBrightonYourHealth

  80. I can’t thank you enough for posting this recipe, I’ve literally been searching for it over 20 years. The miracles of the internet never cease to amaze me.

  81. Found your recipe after having a good search on the net. Followed it to the letter (but made x3 the amount – if I was going to cook something for 4+ hours I was going to be sure to make a big batch!). What a revelation. Meaty, thick, packed with flavour. Had it with penne the first night, tagliatelle the 2nd. Really enjoyed it the 2nd time, ala true Bolognan style. Just a few tips as I’m actually currently cooking it the 2nd time right now – the pancetta adds a lot of saltiness to it; I found I didn’t need much at all. And did have to add a bit more milk to it at the 4+ hour mark as it was drying out a bit and catching at the bottom of the dish. May true it with half milk/half stock to try something different.

    Anyways, thanks very much for sharing. Fantastic recipe :)

    • Yes Derrick I’m always amazed how much it can absorb more and more milk. But that just seems to make it meatier and meatier!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s